the porous city

One of the stickiest problems in education is the issue of language and dialect. Schools tend to teach kids a variety of English that is used by the middle and upper classes. This can alienate kids from poorer backgrounds - why do we need the learn the language of the oppressor?

Basil Bernstein's work says: because if you want to explain new ideas, you need a different style of language ("elaborated code") than the day-to-day vernacular ("restricted code"). "Restricted/condensed code is therefore great for shared, established and static meanings (and values): but if you want to break out to say something new, particularly something which questions the received wisdom, you are going to have to use an elaborated code."

2/12/2014 Update: interesting take on the cultural functions of the restricted code. Also points out that Bernstein's later work became more specific about how language reproduces the division of labor.


last modified: 20:36:02 17-Jul-2007
in categories:Arts/Rhetoric

2 Comments

Wait, so how does this work for middle/upper class kids for whom the elaborated code is already close to their restricted code? Really, there are new ways of speaking being introduced to both groups. It's just a question of degree: how different is the elaborated code from the restricted code? My guess is that more different isn't necessarily better for learning. I'm certainly not going to learn anything if you try to lecture me immediately in Morse code, for example. Most likely there's an optimum level of divergence. Where does the optimum lie? I'm sure that teachers experiment with that on a daily basis...

posted by Eric Nguyen mail homepage

- - -

So the benefit of the elaborated code for education doesn't come from making people learn a new style of communication. If they already know the elaborated code it's fine. It's about the fact that the elaborated code is designed to spell everything out explicitly, so it can communicate new information with less possibility of transmission error. The restricted code is designed to spell out as little as possible (it's more compressed based on knowledge shared by all users of the same restricted code.) That makes it better for day-to-day social interactions with in-group members (because the compression based on shared in-group knowledge binds the in-group more tightly together, and because the compression makes communication more efficient.)

posted by Lukas

- - -

name*

email

homepage

No html.

what's the second letter of your name?

This is Lukas Bergstrom's weblog. You can also find me on Twitter and LinkedIn.

Tech
Data, Visual, s60, Android, Crowdsourcing, Product Management, Automobile, Javascript, Business, Security, Shopping, Web analytics, PIM, Web, WRX, Development, RSS, Medical, Net, OS, MacOS, Energy, Storage, Audio, Hardware, Mobile, Open, AI, Wearables, barcamp, a11y, Social, Collaboration

Other
Food & Drink, Boston, Podcasts, Statistics, Housing, Politik, Law, Surfing, Video, Agriculture, Life hacks, Bicycling, Transportation, San Francisco, Toys, Friday, L.A., Activism, History, California, Minnesota, Berlin, Travel, Games, Feminism, Clothes, NYC, Personal care, Geography, Quizzes, Sports, CrowdFlower

Music
L.A., Boston, Hip-hop, Mp3s, Videos, Lyrics, Shopping, Booking, House, Musicians, Events, Streams, Reviews, Making, Mixes, Good tracks, Labels, Business, History, Mailing lists

People
Life hacks, Gossip, Meditation, Subcultures, Vocations, Languages, Enemies, Me, Working with, MOTAS, Family, Stories, Buddhism, Exercise, ADD, Heroes, Health, Weblogs, Friends

Arts
Spoken Word, Rhetoric, Movies, iPad bait, Animation, Visual, Poetry, Comix, Sculpture, Burning Man, Events, Humor, Literature, Outlets, Desktop wallpaper bait

Commerce
Investing, IP Law, Personal services, Macroeconomics, Non-profit, Shopping, Management consulting, Taxes, Web, Personal finance, International Development, Real Estate, Insurance, Microfinance, Marketing and CRM

Design
Process, Data visualization, User experience, IA, Presentations, Type, Furniture, Algorithmic, Web, Tools, Architecture, Cool

Science
Physics, Cognition, Psychology, Zoology, Statistics and Data, Networks, Environment

Travel
Kenya, Vagabond '08, Kingdom of Siam, Uganda

Photos
Photos I Wish I'd Taken, Moblog, Friends

Philosophy
Mind

Internet classic

Mathematics

One Acre Fund

Subscribe to this site's rss feed